NATO grapples with trust gap as militaries bet on private tech and AI
NATO commanders and defence officials met in Izmir, Turkey for three days of talks on digital warfare, and ran straight into an awkward question: how much of the battlefield can be outsourced to private companies. Ukraine's reliance on SpaceX's Starshield, and Elon Musk's shifting stance, keeps the dilemma front and centre.
- Original source: france24.com.
- The source published it on Nov 22, 2026 at 9:34 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
NATO's military chiefs, government officials and defence experts from all 32 member states — plus Ukraine — spent three days in Izmir, Turkey this week at NATO Edge, a conference on critical technologies and digital warfare. The topic dominating the room: how much of national defence can be handed to private companies without handing over sovereignty.
The sharpest example is in the sky. Ukraine depends on SpaceX's Starlink network and its military sibling Starshield, and has faced restrictions on Starshield access since Russia's full-scale invasion in 2022. Elon Musk has shifted his position on Ukraine repeatedly, and has said any disruption was Washington's responsibility rather than SpaceX's.
Tom Barton, an analyst at intelligence firm Janes, put the squeeze plainly: ministries of defence are wrestling with a hard question, because companies need some access to confidential data if they are to build the so-called networked battlefield. Defence establishments are experimenting with standalone exercises and with varying levels of trust and access, he said. A US company representative, speaking on condition of anonymity, said there is heavy advocacy for government and industry to work closer — but warned there's a fine line, pointing at Musk's interventions in Ukraine.
Major General Rainer Beeck, one of NATO's top cyberspace commanders, called it a hard nut to crack. Commanders have to decide which data gets which classification level, he said, and the real problem is trust. Admiral Pierre Vandier, NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Transformation, agreed trust is the most important thing — trust in architecture, data sharing, AI agents and decision-making tools — and said the fighter-factory gap needs closing, something he credited Ukraine with doing. Kyiv has nearly five years of war behind it, more experience than any NATO member.
Money changes the equation. Beeck said big powers don't struggle to collect data, but would find it too late to organise if a war started, and he wants a more proactive approach. Mitch Free, vice president of international government at satellite imagery provider Vantor, said smaller governments have to build up capacity, and many own only a handful of satellites — weighing their intelligence value against the cost of building and operating them. That, he said, is where commercial providers help fill the gap.
Jean-Charles Ellermann-Kingombe, NATO's cyber and digital transformation chief, said the bottleneck is usually not technology but permission — classification boundaries, national rules and trust decisions. The alliance, he said, has to make AI adoption possible at scale, with capabilities that are secure, interoperable and deployable inside NATO's infrastructure by personnel who understand both their value and their limits.
TopicsNATO · SpaceX · Starshield · Elon Musk · Ukraine · Rainer Beeck · Pierre Vandier · Jean-Charles Ellermann-Kingombe
Source: france24.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Politics & world euronews.com Caught by @umam 0 viewsEuronews veteran Attila Kert picked to run Hungary's public broadcaster
- Politics & world theguardian.com Caught by @pz162090 0 viewsUK-EU food deal wins over British exporters, but not until 2028
- Politics & world breakingthenews.net 0 viewsDrone hits UN office in Khartoum while staff were inside
- Politics & world legit.ng 1 viewAtiku Urged to Quit 2027 Race and Retire as Group Questions His Record

