MP Slams Jersey and Guernsey Company Ownership Register Plans as Too Weak
Guernsey and Jersey want to let journalists, academics and other approved applicants peek at who really owns companies — but only when investigating suspected financial crime. Westminster MP Sir Andrew Mitchell says that falls far short, warning national security threats could stay invisible to investigators. Both islands insist they still meet international standards.
- Original source: bbc.com.
- The source published it on Nov 22, 2026 at 7:22 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
Sir Andrew Mitchell, the Westminster MP who has spent years pushing for tougher scrutiny of company ownership, tore into fresh proposals from Guernsey and Jersey on Tuesday, saying they 'do not go nearly far enough.' He claimed there were 'immediate indications' the plans would miss the mark, and warned that limits on who gets access could leave 'national security threats... entirely invisible to investigators.'
The two islands unveiled plans to let journalists, academics and other applicants with a legitimate interest request information about who ultimately owns or controls companies. Right now, that data is mostly locked to law enforcement agencies, regulators and certain regulated businesses running anti-money laundering checks. The move follows a joint pledge Guernsey, Jersey and the Isle of Man made in December 2023 to boost ownership transparency and fight money laundering and terrorist financing.
Mitchell flagged a 'catch-22' — investigators may need the register itself to prove wrongdoing in the first place. He also objected to applicants having to show they already failed to find the information elsewhere, saying: 'This entirely defeats the object of a register.' Jersey's consultation response backs that requirement, stating applicants must show 'all reasonable alternative sources have been exhausted.' Guernsey's published response does not spell out the same condition.
The MP pushed for wider reach too, arguing: 'Access should be open to those from other jurisdictions, for example those in the global south from whom much of the world's dirty money was stolen in the first place.' He also questioned whether users would have to pay, insisting 'this information should be free at the point of access,' and said the proposals should eventually deliver fully public registers.
Both governments hit back. A Government of Jersey spokesperson said Mitchell's concerns 'do not accurately reflect what is in Jersey's consultation response paper,' describing the policy as balancing international commitments with 'a fair, proportionate, and effective transparency framework,' and adding that Jersey 'continues to meet international standards for transparency and countering money laundering, terrorist financing and proliferation financing.'
Guernsey rejected the criticism just as bluntly. A spokesperson said the island 'does not accept the suggestion that our proposals fall short of the commitments we've made on beneficial ownership transparency,' adding that the framework opens access to those with a legitimate interest in investigating crime while shielding privacy and vulnerable people. 'The proposal is based on a tried and tested model adopted in the EU,' the spokesperson said.
TopicsSir Andrew Mitchell · Guernsey · Jersey · Isle of Man · Government of Jersey
Source: bbc.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Politics & world abc.net.au Caught by @krisnanugroho 0 viewsWong Puts AI on the Security Front Line in Parliament Speech
- Politics & world theguardian.com 0 viewsConservative media cracks open over Trump after midterm wipeout
- Politics & world euronews.com Caught by @umam 0 viewsPhantom Iranian tanker was a spoof, tracker says, as Hormuz blockade hits 130 days
- Politics & world bbc.co.uk Caught by @teguhramadhan 0 viewsMay, Cameron and Blair weigh in on Burnham's EU plan

