Census Bureau's 2030 Overhaul Draws 148,850 Comments, 88% Against
Nearly 149,000 people weighed in on the Census Bureau's plan to exclude most noncitizens and drop race and ethnicity questions from the 2030 count, and 88% of them said no. A Hands Off Our Census analysis found the loudest opposition in California, New York, Florida and Pennsylvania. The Bureau still isn't required to listen.
- Original source: forbes.com.
- The source published it on Nov 21, 2026 at 12:00 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
The Census Bureau's proposed overhaul of the 2030 count has drawn 148,850 public comments, and 88% of them oppose it, according to a new analysis by Hands Off Our Census, a nonpartisan coalition of statistics and policy groups. The group reviewed every comment filed between Sept. 10 and Nov. 4, finding the heaviest pushback from California, New York, Florida and Pennsylvania. The Bureau unveiled the proposals in September.
The rule would strip noncitizens who are not lawful permanent residents from the population totals used to apportion U.S. House seats, a change that would hit communities heavy with temporary visa holders, international students, refugees and undocumented residents. It also deletes the race and ethnicity questions that have appeared on the decennial form since 1790, bars any question on sexual orientation, replaces the single April 1 Census Day with a three-month window, and uses tax records to decide where a person spends most of their days. The Commerce Department and Census Bureau say the goal is to base representation on citizens and permanent residents, ease responding and protect privacy by limiting demographic disclosures.
Supporters include 22 Republican state attorneys general, several state lawmakers and restrictionist advocacy campaigns, who argue noncitizens shouldn't dilute citizens' voting power or skew apportionment. Against them: a coalition of 20 Democratic state attorneys general plus D.C., more than 340 state, local and tribal entities, 58 tribal governments, the National League of Cities, the U.S. Conference of Mayors, and cities including Los Angeles, New York City, Detroit and Milwaukee. The American Medical Association and the National Education Association also weighed in, as did the American Statistical Association, the Population Association of America, the Association of Public Data Users, the Population Reference Bureau and the Federation of American Scientists Data Policy Institute. Critics say excluding noncitizens violates the 14th Amendment's mandate to count the “whole number of persons in each State,” that tax records will miss millions of low-income non-filers and children, and that killing the race data cripples Voting Rights Act enforcement.
“It is very hard to say what the impact will be in 2030 in terms of who wins and loses seats or federal money, but it's very easy to say that everyone will lose quality of data,” said Christopher Dick, a data scientist with Hands Off Our Census. “Everyone will have a less clear picture of who lives in their communities. Every single poll done in this country will be worse.” Meeta Anand, senior director for census and data equity at The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, called the changes “going to render public data unusable by the people who need to use it.”
The Bureau's own Preliminary Regulatory Impact Analysis concedes that dropping the questions and full counts will degrade the accuracy of the American Community Survey and other federal data that drive funding formulas, infrastructure planning and public health metrics.
Public opinion alone doesn't force the Bureau to back down. It must review the comments, answer the biggest concerns and ship a final draft to the White House Office of Management and Budget; once OMB signs off, the rule lands in the Federal Register and takes effect within 30 to 60 days. Congress could overturn it with a two-thirds majority, though Hands Off Our Census spokespeople call that unlikely. States, cities, tribal governments and civil rights groups could instead sue after publication, and federal judges could freeze the rule while courts weigh whether it violates the 14th Amendment.
TopicsCensus Bureau · Hands Off Our Census · Christopher Dick · Meeta Anand · Office of Management and Budget · American Medical Association · National Education Association · The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights
Source: forbes.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Politics & world breakingthenews.net Caught by @putri.santoso56 0 viewsChina Accuses FCC of Power Grab Over US Phone Number Ban
- Politics & world x.com 1 viewTop Democrat Threatens to Cut Government Funding for Musk's SpaceX
- Politics & world breakingthenews.net 1 viewBlasts shake Kyiv after 2am as Russian drones approach
- Politics & world nbcnews.com Caught by @bayu.saputra80 1 viewPoland says Russian missile that hit its territory was likely intentional

