Appeals court strikes down Biden's $1.7T spending law over proxy votes
A federal appeals court ruled 9-8 that the 2022 $1.7 trillion spending law is unconstitutional because proxy votes don't count toward a quorum. The ruling blocks the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act's enforcement in Texas, granting AG Ken Paxton's request. A dissent warns the majority is rewriting the Constitution's quorum rules.
- Original source: us.cnn.com.
- The source published it on Nov 21, 2026 at 6:58 PM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
A federal appeals court ruled Friday that the $1.7 trillion pandemic-era spending law Congress passed in 2022 is unconstitutional — because lawmakers let colleagues cast their votes by proxy. The 9-8 decision from the full appellate panel found proxy votes don't count toward a quorum under the Constitution's clause governing congressional meetings.
The numbers were central to the case. The omnibus bill cleared the House 225 to 201, with one member voting present, and according to the court's opinion, 226 lawmakers voted by proxy under accommodations in place while coronavirus infection risk stayed high. Judge Cory Wilson, a Trump appointee who wrote the majority opinion, said the government never established an 'existence of an emergency' when it adopted proxy voting. A district court judge reached the same conclusion back in 2022.
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton brought the case in 2023, aiming to block the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act — which requires some employers to provide accommodations for pregnant workers — from being enforced in Texas. He recently lost his bid for US Senate. Friday's ruling hands him the result he asked for. Legal experts had warned a ruling against the law's passage could ripple across other bills passed by proxy, but the majority insisted its decision has a 'narrow scope,' applying only to enforcement of a Texas provision covering workplace conditions for pregnant women.
Judge James Graves Jr., an Obama appointee, dissented. He wrote that 'even though less than a majority was physically present at the time of the vote, no Member objected that a quorum was lacking,' and said requiring lawmakers to be physically present 'shoehorns a much larger requirement into the Constitution.'
Beyond the Texas workplace provision, the 2022 bill funded government operations across federal agencies. It also carried roughly $45 billion in emergency assistance to Ukraine and NATO allies and about $40 billion for natural disaster relief.
TopicsJoe Biden · Ken Paxton · Cory Wilson · James Graves Jr. · Pregnant Workers Fairness Act · Texas · US Congress
Source: us.cnn.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Politics & world breakingthenews.net 0 viewsIAEA: Ukrainian Nuclear Plant Cuts Output After Two Power Lines Go Down
- Politics & world news.bitcoin.com 1 view44 State AGs Slam CFTC's Prediction Market Power Grab
- Politics & world breakingthenews.net 2 viewsAoun points at Israel and Iran as brakes on Lebanese sovereignty
- Politics & world independent.co.uk Caught by @madekurniawan 0 viewsICE recruits trained online instead of in person, some in under a day

