Poll: Stay-home Trump voters, not party switchers, drove the Blue Tsunami
A J.L. Partners postmortem finds 35% of Trump's 2024 voters didn't vote on Nov. 3, while only 8% switched to Democrats. That turnout collapse alone accounts for 10 of the 15-point swing to Democrats — and the firm says it would have flipped both chambers of Congress.
- Original source: nypost.com.
- The source published it on Nov 16, 2026 at 3:59 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
Republicans didn't get swamped by a wave of defectors this month — they got swamped by their own voters staying on the couch. A new postmortem poll from J.L. Partners found 35% of Trump's 2024 voters didn't cast a ballot on Nov. 3, while just 8% actually switched sides to Democrats.
That sitting-out alone explains 10 points of the 15-point swing toward Democrats since 2024, the firm calculated. The switchers accounted for the other five. J.L. Partners ran an Election Day survey of 1,000 registered voters and checked it against more than 30,000 interviews conducted during the campaign.
The drop-off hit Trump's core hardest: 46% of his 2024 voters without a college degree skipped the election, along with 44% of those over 65 and 39% in rural areas. The firm concluded the low turnout by itself would have flipped Congress. Founding director James Johnson put it bluntly — even with zero voters switching, the GOP would have lost the Senate and House.
The numbers back Trump's own explanation that his name wasn't on the ballot, even though he campaigned as if it were. Johnson told The Post that a Trump-on-the-ballot scenario would have produced a better result. It also cuts against Vice President JD Vance, who wrote on X the day after the election that turnout wasn't the main problem and blamed Trump voters who crossed over. Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis landed on the other side on Fox News, saying stay-home voters were frustrated by the lack of productivity from Republicans in the House and Senate.
The defectors who did flip were a younger, more male, more nonwhite and more urban crowd — the voters Trump added in 2024. Sixteen percent of under-30 Trump voters backed a Democrat for the House. Johnson thinks they haven't gone far: half of the defectors still view the GOP favorably and 41% approve of Trump's job performance, which he suggested could be a gateway into politics rather than a permanent exit.
Democrats don't come out of the poll smelling like roses either. Nearly half of Democratic voters, 48%, described their ballot as a vote against Trump rather than for anything their party proposed, and only 30% of registered voters said the party has a 2028-ready presidential candidate — with 29% of Democrats themselves saying no. Cost of living was the top issue for every group measured, and while just 3% named the Iran war as their top concern, Johnson said it sits underneath the rest: voters in the firm's focus groups know costs are higher because of the war. The poll's margin of error is 3.4 percentage points overall and 10.5 for the 87 defectors.
TopicsJ.L. Partners · Donald Trump · James Johnson · JD Vance · Ron DeSantis · Republican Party · Democratic Party · MAGA
Source: nypost.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.

