Ninth Circuit Judges Pile On Nexstar Over Slimmed-Down Tegna Merger Freeze
A three-judge Ninth Circuit panel grilled Nexstar's lawyer over its push to freeze only 31 stations in its $6.2 billion Tegna deal, not the whole merger. DirecTV and 13 state attorneys general are fighting to unwind the tie-up, and a ruling isn't expected until early 2027.
- Original source: deadline.com.
- The source published it on Nov 17, 2026 at 11:54 PM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
Nexstar Media Group caught heat in a Pasadena courtroom as three federal appellate judges repeatedly cut off its lawyer, Deanne Maynard, during oral arguments over the company's contested Tegna acquisition. Judges Marsha Berzon, Johnnie Rawlinson and Xavier Rodriguez pressed Maynard on her argument that a temporary restraining order should cover only the 31 markets where Nexstar and Tegna both own stations, rather than the entire deal. Maynard said the plaintiffs had accepted that narrower scope in appeal briefs and called holding separate stations common in broadcast mergers.
The panel wasn't buying a clear playbook. Berzon said her main concern is that an appellate court shouldn't redo the district court's work without very high confidence a feasible alternative exists, calling the question one that requires understanding how a large integrated organization functions. Rodriguez floated sending the matter back down, asking why the court has to decide anything now.
DirecTV and attorneys general from 13 states sued last March to block the $6.2 billion transaction, which would reach some 80% of U.S. households. The FCC approved it the next day and Nexstar declared it closed, but a federal judge then froze the deal pending trial. Tegna shareholders were paid and its stock stopped trading, while its Virginia operations stayed separate from Nexstar's Texas footprint. Eight months in, Nexstar stock has slipped 10%.
California Department of Justice attorney Emily Curran called focusing on 31 stations instead of Tegna's full portfolio incoherent, saying plaintiffs presented evidence that fully restoring the previous Tegna would bring back lost competition. DirecTV's Ben Horwich said plaintiffs challenged the transaction Nexstar put together, and it isn't their job or the court's to fashion a different one. He pointed to Sinclair-Tribune and Tegna's failed Standard General combination as deals undone by antitrust concerns.
Horwich also argued carving out 31 stations clashes with Nexstar's own thesis that scale is needed to compete, saying it would amount to creating orphan stations and hunting for homes for them. The judges took the case under advisement after arguments and are expected to decide in early 2027. If Nexstar loses, it can seek an en banc hearing or appeal to the Supreme Court. A jury trial is set for next July in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of California.
TopicsNexstar Media Group · Tegna · DirecTV · FCC · Deanne Maynard · Marsha Berzon · Xavier Rodriguez · Standard General
Source: deadline.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Business & markets x.com 1 viewGold drops below $3,800, its first time there since September 2025
- Business & markets channelnewsasia.com Caught by @Fahri 1 viewBOJ's Ueda Says Rate Hikes Should Keep Coming
- Business & markets x.com 1 viewUS margin debt slips $32B in October but holds 4th-highest level on record
- Business & markets finance.yahoo.com 1 viewDow Plunges 848 Points as NSA Network Outage Rattles Tech Stocks

