Ministers accused of gambling with safety over maternity repair costs
The Liberal Democrats say ministers are risking mothers' and babies' lives after NHS minister Karin Smyth admitted she cannot say what it would cost to repair England's crumbling maternity units. NHS England says 43% of units fail basic safety standards, with 14,519 reports of care disrupted by shoddy buildings in three years.
- Original source: theguardian.com.
- The source published it on Nov 16, 2026 at 5:00 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
Karin Smyth, the NHS minister at the Department of Health and Social Care, told parliament she cannot put a figure on what it would cost to fix maternity and neonatal units that NHS England believes need major repair or replacement soon — or are at serious risk of imminent breakdown. She was answering questions tabled by Helen Morgan, the Liberal Democrats' health spokesperson.
Morgan didn't hold back. She said NHS England had spelled out that dozens of maternity units are falling apart, and called it appalling that the government still has no idea what making every unit fit for purpose would cost. Ministers, she said, are gambling with the safety of mothers, babies and the NHS staff caring for them.
The state of the estate is laid out in the Amos review of childbirth services, published in the summer, which found leaking roofs and rooms swinging between too hot and too cold at Musgrove Park hospital in Taunton, Somerset. The unit's antenatal ward is being held up by metal poles. Bosses at Musgrove Park conceded in September the unit is old, outdated and cramped after CQC inspectors found water leaking into clinical areas and mould on the walls of the postnatal ward — though care was rated good.
At Stepping Hill hospital in Stockport, Jules Wilkinson held up a light that had come loose from the ceiling for an hour while his wife gave birth to their daughter Cora; it narrowly missed a midwife. Chief executive Karen James believes the 121-year-old hospital, which regularly leaks, needs £400m to be safe for patients and staff.
NHS England's September 2025 review of maternity and neonatal infrastructure found 14,519 formally reported instances over three years where poor physical conditions interrupted clinical services or hit delivery — problems like power outages and faulty nurse call systems that can delay planned caesarean sections. The CQC warned in 2024 that too many units are not fit for purpose and pose serious safety risks for women and babies. St Helier hospital in Sutton, south London, is relocating its maternity services because repairs can't be done safely alongside births, said trust chief executive Mat Shaw.
In last month's budget, ministers cut £1bn from the NHS capital budget over the next four years to help fund defence spending, even as the cost of clearing the NHS maintenance backlog climbed to £17.3bn. Ciarán Devane of the NHS Alliance said many maternity units sit in outdated, decaying buildings, adding to pressures including staffing and the size and location of units. The DHSC blamed the Conservatives for failing to maintain the NHS estate, pointing to £271m invested since April 2025 in critical maternity safety schemes, more than £1.5bn announced for NHS buildings and a capital budget rising to £15bn in 2029-30.
TopicsNHS England · Liberal Democrats · Helen Morgan · Karin Smyth · Care Quality Commission · Musgrove Park hospital · Stepping Hill hospital · Department of Health and Social Care
Source: theguardian.com
Written by AI from verified reporting. Not financial advice.

