Congress analysts warn Aukus sub sales would shrink US Navy for years
A Congressional Budget Office report out Friday says handing Virginia-class submarines to Australia under Aukus would cut the number of attack subs available to the US Navy for years. American shipyards are building 1.13 boats a year, far below the 2.33 rate needed to spare any for Australia. Critics call the whole arrangement a fiction.
- Original source: theguardian.com.
- The source published it on Nov 20, 2026 at 12:16 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
The Congressional Budget Office dropped its analysis Friday morning, and the verdict is blunt: selling three to five in-service Virginia-class submarines to Australia would leave the US Navy with fewer attack submarines for years. The report also finds the US submarine industrial base is already straining to keep up with the Navy's own demand, and that lifting production further to backfill boats sent to Australia would pile more pressure on shipyards.
The production numbers are ugly. US yards are turning out Virginia-class submarines at 1.13 a year, while two a year is needed just to serve America's own needs, and 2.33 a year would be required to have extra boats for Australia. Building one of these submarines took five to six years in the 2000s; it now averages 10 to 11 years, with Virginia-class deliveries running 24 to 36 months late.
The Navy's latest shipbuilding plan doesn't account for Aukus at all. A single footnote notes that the transfer of any Virginia-class submarine to Australia has not been factored into the plan, according to the report.
Then there's the question of who actually commands the boats. The CBO asks whether China would be less deterred if the US thinned its own attack fleet to help Australia build one. Australia would control its submarines, so their use in any conflict isn't guaranteed. Defence minister Richard Marles said in 2023 that Australia promises nothing about deploying subs in a US-China conflict, and that future Australian boats would sit under the complete control of the Australian government of the day. US law only permits a transfer if losing the submarine won't degrade American undersea capabilities, and the US can walk away from any transfer without penalty.
Pushback is loud. Former foreign affairs minister Bob Carr told Guardian Australia the two countries are living a lie by pretending the deal will happen, saying it's now conventional wisdom in Washington and Canberra that the subs won't arrive. Marles countered this month that Aukus is happening and the alliance continues unimpeded, and US defence secretary Pete Hegseth reaffirmed support at a September meeting with Marles. A January Congressional Research Service report floated an alternative: keep the boats under US command and sail them out of Australian bases instead.
TopicsCongressional Budget Office · US Navy · Australia · Aukus · Richard Marles · Bob Carr · Pete Hegseth · Virginia-class submarines
Source: theguardian.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Politics & world theguardian.com Caught by @@harrison 0 viewsDrop religion from terrorism law, Australian security watchdog urges
- Politics & world x.com 0 viewsUSDA Suffers Cyberattack, Forcing Multiple Government Systems Offline
- Politics & world bbc.co.uk 0 viewsInside Besieged Taiz, a Mother Tells Her Son the Shelling Is Just Fireworks
- Politics & world edition.cnn.com Caught by @hani1302 0 viewsIranian plot suspect storms NY court, shouts innocence and demands new lawyers

