Australian Music Industry Rejects AI Copyright Carveout for Musicians
Australia's music industry has refused a reported plan to exempt musicians from AI scraping while other creatives get no such protection. ARIA and the Writers' Guild say they'll stay united against it, as politicians from Pocock to Cash pile on.
- Original source: theguardian.com.
- The source published it on Nov 19, 2026 at 2:00 PM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
Australia's music industry won't take a special deal if it means other creatives get left behind. The Australian Financial Review reported Thursday that the Albanese government is weighing a copyright change letting AI companies buy permits to train on Australian content, with music potentially exempted. ARIA chief executive Annabelle Herd said she only heard about it on Thursday, and the answer is no. The Australian Writers' Guild, which represents writers and creatives, called the idea alarming.
Herd didn't mince words about the proposal itself. Had the industry been consulted, she told Guardian Australia, it would have advised the scheme is unnecessary, unworkable and built to serve AI companies' commercial interests rather than protect creators. Her position hasn't moved: music stands with the rest of the creative and media industries. Writers' Guild chief executive Claire Pullen echoed that solidarity, saying she can't see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind.
The reported plan didn't find friends in parliament either. Independent senator David Pocock called it a divide and conquer strategy, and questioned why the government is acting before the joint select committee has even delivered its report. Shadow attorney general Michaelia Cash said the tactic would split rightsholders and should be strongly resisted. Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young warned Australia would become known as the Cayman Islands for AI if the loophole passes, telling the government: don't be that stupid.
Pullen argued the exemption would also be a technical mess, asking how a film or TV show combining music, video and screenwriting gets treated when only one element is carved out. She said AI companies have had an open invitation to negotiate for years, that the industry has worked with government on a model since 2024, and that tech has steadfastly refused to talk. The Media, Entertainment & Arts Alliance said it would be alarmed too, demanding the protections Anthony Albanese promised apply to all creative sectors.
The government wouldn't comment on the reported proposal, and Guardian Australia couldn't independently verify its details. One senior creative figure involved in copyright talks had heard some of it; others hadn't and doubted it would be taken seriously. One unnamed AI industry source said they'd welcome the plan. Meanwhile the rhetoric from senior Labor is hardening: industry minister Tim Ayres said Tuesday the status quo is no good, acting prime minister Richard Marles repeated it Thursday and added that people are being ripped off, and attorney general Michelle Rowland promised certainty and strong protections for Australian artists, noting their work is being used without consent or payment.
The idea echoes positions AI firms have already floated. Anthropic has suggested a conditional approval model that scrapes content unless a rightsholder objects, and OpenAI told a parliamentary committee it would potentially support paying into a fund for creators. Some AI companies argue individual licensing deals are too difficult under current copyright law — a claim major rightsholder groups reject.
TopicsARIA · Australian Writers' Guild · Annabelle Herd · Claire Pullen · David Pocock · Sarah Hanson-Young · Michaelia Cash · Michelle Rowland
Source: theguardian.com
Written by AI from verified reporting.
More stories
- Tech & AI cryptobriefing.com 1 viewJensen Huang resigns as Nvidia CEO amid affair scandal; shares plunge more than 30%
- Tech & AI x.com 0 viewsAnthropic's $1.5T odds slide to 29% as $ANT trading nears
- Tech & AI economictimes.indiatimes.com 2 sources 0 viewsAnthropic Hits the Market With Ticker ANT, and Tokens Are the Number to Watch
- Tech & AI cryptopolitan.com 3 viewsOpenAI's models rewrite AMD and Jalapeño chip circuits, up to 14% gains

