Alaska's Two Dan Sullivans: Data Punctures Trump's Confusion Claim
Alaska's Senate race is still uncalled nearly two weeks after the midterms, with Democrat Mary Peltola at 49.94% as of Monday and the incumbent Dan S Sullivan trailing. BBC Verify's look at ranked-choice second preferences undercuts claims that voters confused the two Dan Sullivans on the ballot.
- Original source: bbc.co.uk.
- The source published it on Nov 17, 2026 at 2:38 AM.
- No second outlet has reported it yet. Treat it as a single-source claim.
Alaska is still counting. Nearly two weeks after the 3 November midterms, Democrat Mary Peltola sits at 49.94% of the vote as of Monday, with Republican Senator Dan S Sullivan behind in a race US media has not forecasted — the last Senate seat without a winner. Daniel J Sullivan Jr, a retired school teacher from a remote fishing village who entered the race in May with a low-key campaign, is in last place at 1.65%.
President Donald Trump has posted repeatedly on Truth Social since the election calling the race rigged, and said last week that anyone who voted for the second Dan Sullivan, the fake one, was supposed to be voting for the real one. The numbers do not back that up. With 97% of the vote counted, BBC Verify reports that even combining Daniel J Sullivan Jr's votes with the incumbent's would still not overcome Peltola's lead.
Alaska uses ranked-choice voting, so voters rank up to five candidates in order of preference; if nobody clears 50% of first preferences, the last-place candidate is eliminated and those ballots flow to the next choices. BBC Verify's analysis of those second preferences found 38% of voters who put Daniel J Sullivan Jr first left their second choice blank. Another 29% ranked Peltola second, almost double the 15% who put Senator Sullivan second.
That undercuts the confusion argument, according to experts. Richard Pildes, a constitutional law professor at New York University, argued the likelihood that any mix-up played a significant role is diminished in Alaska, because any voter unsure which Dan Sullivan they meant could rank them first and second. On the ballots themselves, the candidates appeared as Sullivan, Daniel J. Jr. and Sullivan, Dan S. (Registered Republican) Incumbent.
The contest drew scrutiny after The New York Times reported before Election Day that Democratic operatives with links to the Peltola campaign tried to recruit spoiler candidates, naming Daniel J Sullivan Jr and a second registered Republican, Gerald Heikes. The BBC has not independently verified that reporting. Peltola has denied all knowledge of the alleged scheme, and Sullivan Jr has denied any links with her campaign.
Not that recruiting would be illegal. Joshua Douglas, an election law expert at the University of Kentucky, said there is nothing to prevent a campaign from recruiting someone else to run, even for political reasons. Ruth Greenwood, director of the election law clinic at Harvard Law School, said no specific law stops people with the same name from running, though states regulate how names appear on the ballot — and one of those rules was used in Alaska. Peltola said on Saturday she will decisively be elected as Alaska's next senator.
TopicsMary Peltola · Dan S Sullivan · Daniel J Sullivan Jr · Donald Trump · The New York Times · Richard Pildes · Joshua Douglas · Ruth Greenwood
Source: bbc.co.uk
Written by AI from verified reporting.

